Skip to content
LESSON NOTES · 02

2. Separate nuclei; antisymmetrize electrons

Position in the course: Lesson 2 of 10. Complete the preceding derivation and use the explained exercises to check understanding.

Prerequisites: Variational principle; products and determinants

Prerequisite lessons: Variational principle and finite bases

1. Conventions

Use fixed nuclear coordinates \(R\), electronic coordinates \(x=(r,\sigma)\) with spin summation, and atomic units: energy in hartree, length in bohr. Molecular orbitals are one-electron functions used to build a many-electron state, not labeled electrons’ trajectories.

2. Separate electronic and nuclear terms

Start with the nonrelativistic Coulomb Hamiltonian. Solve the electronic problem at each chosen nuclear geometry; electronic energy plus nuclear repulsion defines a potential-energy surface. Expand the full state in geometry-dependent electronic eigenstates.

\[ \begin{aligned}H&=T_N+H_e(R)+V_{NN}(R),\\H_e&=\sum_i\left[-\tfrac12\nabla_i^2-\sum_A\frac{Z_A}{|r_i-R_A|}\right]+\sum_{i<j}\frac1{r_{ij}},\\H_e(R)\psi_k(x;R)&=E_{e,k}(R)\psi_k(x;R),\quad\Psi(x,R)=\sum_k\chi_k(R)\psi_k(x;R).\end{aligned} \]

3. See exactly what Born–Oppenheimer drops

Nuclear kinetic energy differentiates both factors. The product rule produces derivative couplings; dropping them at leading order gives a single-surface nuclear equation. Heavy nuclei motivate the approximation, but a small electronic gap can make those couplings important. A crossing is not by itself a universal failure criterion.

\[ \nabla_R^2(\chi\psi)=\psi\nabla_R^2\chi+2(\nabla_R\chi)\cdot(\nabla_R\psi)+\chi\nabla_R^2\psi,\quad[T_N+E_{e,k}+V_{NN}]\chi_k=E\chi_k. \]

4. Antisymmetrize complete electron coordinates

Electrons are identical fermions. Exchanging coordinates including spin must change the many-electron sign. For orthonormal spin orbitals, a normalized determinant enforces this: swapping two electron columns changes sign; duplicate occupied orbital rows give zero.

\[ \Phi(x_1,\ldots,x_N)=\frac1{\sqrt{N!}}\det[\varphi_p(x_q)]. \]

Separate nuclei; antisymmetrize electrons — schematic under the stated model assumptions

Teaching schematic drawn from the equations or algorithm steps in this lesson; not measured data.

5. Worked example: shared spatial orbital

Two electrons can occupy one spatial orbital with opposite spin because the spin orbitals differ. The spatial part is symmetric and the singlet spin part antisymmetric, so their product has the required total antisymmetry.

\[ \Phi=\phi(r_1)\phi(r_2)\frac{\alpha(1)\beta(2)-\beta(1)\alpha(2)}{\sqrt2}. \]

6. Check yourself and limits

Is nuclear repulsion omitted from molecular total energy?

Answer and reasoning

No; \(V_{NN}\) is necessary even if constant at one geometry.

Does a determinant capture arbitrary electron correlation?

Answer and reasoning

No; it restricts the many-electron ansatz.

Does heavier nuclear mass guarantee BO validity?

Answer and reasoning

No; the electronic gap and derivative couplings also matter.

7. Surfaces, forces and what is held fixed

The electronic energy and nuclear repulsion together define the chosen adiabatic potential-energy surface. A force is the negative derivative of that total with respect to a nuclear coordinate, not the derivative of electronic energy with nuclear repulsion forgotten. For an exact normalized differentiable electronic eigenstate, differentiating the eigenvalue equation yields the Hellmann-Feynman expression \(dE_e/dR=\langle\psi|\partial_RH_e|\psi\rangle\). Wavefunction derivative terms cancel using normalization and the eigenvalue equation.

In a finite basis attached to moving atoms, the basis functions themselves depend on geometry. Additional Pulay terms may be required in the analytic force. Self-consistency and integral thresholds also affect how accurately the derivative is evaluated. A finite-difference check should use multiple displacement sizes: too large measures curvature rather than a derivative; too small amplifies numerical noise.

The mass-ratio argument for Born-Oppenheimer separation is strongest away from problematic electronic near-degeneracies. Expanding in several electronic states retains derivative couplings and can describe transitions between surfaces. A potential-energy surface is therefore a chosen reduction of coupled electron-nuclear dynamics, not an immutable exact object for every circumstance. Nuclear quantum effects may remain important even when a single electronic surface is valid.

Additional exercise: Suppose \(E_e(R)=-A/R\) and \(V_{NN}(R)=B/R\) in a teaching model. The total force is \((B-A)/R^2\) along increasing \(R\), whereas differentiating \(E_e\) alone gives \(-A/R^2\). Omitting the nuclear contribution can even reverse a qualitative conclusion. The toy energy has no stable finite-radius minimum, so it is not a realistic molecular bond model.

8. References and further reading

Derivations and numerical examples here are original teaching constructions, not copied passages or reported research data.

Quantum mechanics · Density functional theory · Quantum Monte Carlo · Gaussian


Previous lesson · Course overview · Next lesson